Unit Price or TCO: Which Best Defines Optimum MRO Cost Recovery?

By George E. Krauter

October 27, 2017 at 6:09 AM

Does optimum maintenance, repair, and operations (MRO) cost recovery come from reductions in unit price or from decreases in total cost of ownership (TCO)? In many cases, TCO considerations are emerging as the focus of supplier selection.  Although factors other than unit price factor significantly in supplier selection(s), low price was, and is, the principal determinant because it is perceived as measurable.  Since market basket processes compare less than 4% of the buy price change from quote date to contract date, the market basket process is flawed. Obtaining optimum TCO requires that the MRO consumer must eliminate the duplications in their MRO supply chain. That is, apply change procedures that will provide proper support for plant reliability goals.

If it is perceived that TCO considerations provide optimum opportunities to capture measurable savings, the unit price factor becomes but a small factor in supplier selection.  However, there are obstacles in the MRO supply chain that will resist change and detract from obtaining true TCO value.

For example:

  • “I WILL NOT CHANGE; IT WON’T WORK” (Also known as “Not my idea!”)
  • “WE TRIED OUTSOURCING; IT FAILED” (What version failed?  Provider blamed?)
  • “THIS IS THE WAY WE’VE ALWAYS DONE IT” (Change benefits occur in manufacturing; why do MRO procedures remain the same?)
  • “WE HAVE NO TIME TO CHANGE; TOO MANY MRO PROBLEMS” (Classic cause and effect)

The MRO supply chain consists of the manufacturer, the master distributor, the local distributor and the MRO storeroom within the facility. That represents four duplications.  Actually, add a fifth: the areas consisting of “sub stocks” (“back up” critical spares to guard against down time) containing considerable dollars that are duplicated in stores inventory. Each of these companies in the MRO chain has functions that they perform, and each has different and sometimes conflicting agendas.  Each represents a cost factor that is applied to the part when that part is consumed…charged to someone’s budget.  The obstacles to TCO come into play as a result of the different agendas in the chain.

Consider a situation if all of these verticals were owned and controlled by one company.  Would these duplications of cost be allowed under a “lean” program?  Would the personal agendas be allowed to continue to the detriment of the prosperity of the company? They would not. The duplications would be eliminated; so why are they allowed to continue to exist in the current MRO supply chain?

TCO considerations require that the Purchasing function climb up the supply chain ladder and cut the duplications and knock down the barriers.   Supplier selections should center on a supplier’s focus and how that supplier can work in tandem to eliminate duplications and provide TCO goals when the parts are consumed ̶ not purchased ̶ to achieve optimum return on TCO efforts.

The answer?   Establish a process where a selected MRO supplier becomes capable of managing the company’s total MRO supply chain and does so on-site. A mutually conceived statement of work agreement with the right provider will eliminate supply chain duplications and optimize TCO year after year; existing MRO situations that detract from plant reliability are optimized.



Tags: MRO TCO Unit price maintenance operations
Category: Blog Post

George E. Krauter

user_avatar

George Krauter, former founder and president of Industrial Systems Assoc. [I.S.A.] has retired as vice president of Synovos.

Currently, he has initiated, "George Krauter Consulting [GKC]"  for effective reliability and cost recovery for consumers  of MRO materials. George is a recognized authority on the management of the MRO supply chain and support for maintenance reliability programs. His book, "OUTSOURCING MRO...FINDING A BETTER WAY" is available from Amazon and from Reliability Web.com.

He is published in Uptime, Modern Distribution Management, and Supply and Demand Chain Executive. George has conducted seminars across North America, in Europe, and in the U.A.R. as well as a guest speaker at Temple U., Howard U., Duke, and MIT.

George is a graduate of Temple University; he lives with his wife, Joyce, in Bucks County, PA. All grand kids live within eating distance. He can be reached anytime:   georgekrauter@comcast.net.



Please add a comment

You must be logged in to leave a reply. Login »


Related Content

Thought Leadership and the Demise of Your Third-Party MRO Outsourcing Program: Part 4

George E. Krauter

When one defines third-party MRO (3PMRO) success, one assumes that fundamental operations are being executed and that expectations are being met (i.e., ROI goals are surpassed} Read More

Guidance for Addressing the New Talent Acquisition Challenge

Dennis Bouley

The US Labor Department reported in March of this year that there were 6.6 million job openings, a record high. Although most of us applaud these numbers Read More

Millennials in Supply Chain Management Seek Advancement and Development Opportunities

Marisa Brown

Millennials working in the supply chain management field don’t fit the mold that the older generation assumes for them. APQC’s recent study Read More


Supplier Profiles

Staples

Staples Advantage is the one supplier that offers all the business solutions you need, all with the expertise of a specialty vendor. Read More

Digi-Key

It started in 1972 with an idea, a new concept in distribution. Today, Digi-Key Corporation is one of the fastest-growing electronic component distributors in the World. The stimulus for this growth is Digi-Key's customer-centered business philosophy… Read More

Lunney Advisory Group

Lunney Advisory Group was founded in 2007. Our firm is not your typical consulting company. Some members of our firm are highly qualified and experienced industry executives/practitioners while others are full time or adjunct university professors.… Read More


Webcasts

What CEOs Expect Of Purchasing

Guest Contributor

Procurement and supply management leaders have a seat at the table, and management’s expectations are high. But what do CEOs really want, and is purchasing delivering on these expectations? This webcast looks at how procurement and supply management … Read More

Growing Purchasing Influence On Indirect Spending

Guest Contributor

At world-class companies, purchasing’s influence touches just about every area of spending. But, how exactly do procurement teams get to the point where other departments approach them for help with sourcing such indirect categories as human resource… Read More

Procurement-Finance Collaboration

Guest Contributor

Procurement & finance are two business functions which are often at loggerheads with each other. One reason for this is the lack of perception alignment on an important metric of procurement and finance performance - 'savings'. Read More